I love it when right-wingers quote liberals in an attempt to undermine other liberals. They do this through sheer spin and twisted, self-inflicted ignorance.
BS Cairn essentially asserts that the U of M students who took part in a sit-in to fight for worker’s rights (something I’m sure Gandhi would have opposed) are a disgrace to the legacy of MLK because they are unwilling to accept their punishment. His claim is that people that take part in sit-ins should be willing to accept their punishment and that’s where the analysis ends.
Yes, the students should be willing to be suspended for their cause, but to claim that they should accept their sentence without criticism, a fight, or a public outcry of displeasure is simply ridiculous. Using the BS Cairn’s analysis, those that took part in sit-ins in restaurants during the civil rights movement should have expected to be arrested, been arrested, accepted their arrest and called it good. What?
The merit behind the blog’s argument is that civil disobedience should be used as a means to start negotiation and that the U of M students failed. First, it is up for debate if the students have failed: they DID get a meeting with the president (albeit a short one), they have gained the attention of a larger segment of the public and media, they continue to demand discourse, and their not down with their efforts to change U of M policy for the better.
Even if you do believe that the U of M students that participated in the sit-in failed, that doesn’t mean that they betrayed a legacy. Simply because a act of civil disobedience fails doesn’t mean its intentions were not where they should have been. If you buy the BS Cairn’s analysis, only successful protests deserve to be equated to the teachings of MLK and Gandhi.
The BS Cairn’s analysis is so flimsy and erroneous that it is almost laughable. In a rather silly attempt to give the left a “gotcha,” the BS Cairn only succeeded in demonstrating it’s weakness for critical analysis. The post, which I encourage you too read (just to get a better idea of what I’m talking about, if nothing else), is so shallow, twisted, and confused that it hurts.
Last 5 posts by Bob Funk
- 60, here we come! - April 28th, 2009
- Term Limits? Let's Get Rid of 'em - April 28th, 2009
- Montana: "toss up" state, again - October 20th, 2008
- Quote of the Day - October 1st, 2008
- Thoughts from Alaska - September 25th, 2008
Popularity: 43% [?]
{ 2 trackbacks }
{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }
Almost all of the spam here is resulting from track backs to the BS Cairn… they need to do something about their spam problem, because this is annoying – very annoying.
Wow… I didn’t know the Big SKy Cairn is now offering gambling AND auto insurance…